Year School
1948 Murray State
1949 Evansville
1950 Murray State
1951 Murray State
1952 Tennessee Tech
Western Kentucky
1953 Tennessee Tech
1954 Eastern Kentucky
1955 Tennessee Tech
1956 Middle Tennessee
1957 Middle Tennessee
1958 Middle Tennessee
Tennessee Tech
1959 Middle Tennessee
Tennessee Tech
1960 Tennessee Tech
1961 Tennessee Tech
1962 Eastern Kentucky
East Tennessee
Middle Tennessee
Morehead State
1963 Western Kentucky
1964 Middle Tennessee
1965 Middle Tennessee
1966 Morehead State
1967 Eastern Kentucky
1968 Eastern Kentucky
1969 East Tennessee
1970 Western Kentucky
1971 Western Kentucky
1972 Tennessee Tech
1973 Western Kentucky
1974 Eastern Kentucky
1975 Tennessee Tech
1976 Eastern Kentucky
1977 Austin Peay
1978 Western Kentucky
1979 Murray State
1980 Western Kentucky
1981 Eastern Kentucky
1982 Eastern Kentucky
1983 Eastern Kentucky
1984 Eastern Kentucky
1985 Middle Tennessee
1986 Eastern Kentucky
Murray State
1987 Eastern Kentucky
Youngstown State
1988 Eastern Kentucky
1989 Middle Tennessee
1990 Eastern Kentucky
Middle Tennessee
1991 Eastern Kentucky
1992 Middle Tennessee
1993 Eastern Kentucky
1994 Eastern Kentucky
1995 Murray State
1996 Murray State
1997 Eastern Kentucky
1998 Tennessee State
1999 Tennessee State
2000 Western Kentucky
2001 Eastern Illinois
2002 Eastern Illinois
Murray State
2003 Jacksonville State
2004 Jacksonville State
2005 Eastern Illinois