Year Player School
1963 Back - Jim Baker, QB East Tennessee
Line - John Mutchler, E Western Kentucky
1964 Back - Carlton Flatt, QB Austin Peay
Line - John Wheeler, G Murray State
1965 Off. - Teddy Morris, QB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Keith Atchley, G Middle Tennessee
1966 Off. - Tommie Gray, HB Morehead State
Def. - Buddy Pfaadt, B Eastern Kentucky
1967 Off. - Dickie Moore, HB Western Kentucky
Def. - Ron Overbay, B East Tennessee
1968 Off. - Larry Tillman, QB Murray State
Def. - Ron Overbay, B East Tennessee
1969 Off. - Larry Schreiber, HB Tennessee Tech
Def. - Lawrence Brame, DE Western Kentucky
1970 Off. - Larry Graham, QB East Tennessee
Def. - Lawrence Brame, DE Western Kentucky
1971 Off. - Rick Fisher, TB Murray State
Def. - Jim Youngblood, LB Tennessee Tech
1972 Off. - George Greenfield, RB Murray State
Def. - Jim Youngblood, LB Tennessee Tech
1973 Off. - Alan Chadwick, QB East Tennessee
Def. - Lonnie Schuster, DT Western Kentucky
1974 Off. - Everett Talbert, RB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Virgil Livers, DB Western Kentucky
1975 Off. - Mike Moore, FB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Rick Green, LB Western Kentucky
1976 Off. - Ernie House, QB Eastern Kentucky
Off. - Everett Talbert, RB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Biff Madon, LB Western Kentucky
1977 Off. - Phil Simms, QB Morehead State
Def. - Bob Bible, LB Austin Peay
1978 Off. - Danny Johnson, RB Murray State
Def. - Mike Betts, DB Austin Peay
1979 Off. - John Hall, QB Western Kentucky
Def. - Terry Love, DB Murray State
1980 Off. - Sonny Defilippis, QB Austin Peay
Def. - George Floyd, DB Eastern Kentucky
1981 Off. - Gino Gibbs, QB Murray State
Def. - George Floyd, DB Eastern Kentucky
1982 Off. - Steve Bird, WR Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Dennis Mix, DE Middle Tennessee
1983 Off. - James Black, RB Akron
Def. - Dave Arango, DL Akron
1984 Off. - Vince Hall, TB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Fred Harvey, LB Eastern Kentucky
1985 Off. - Marvin Collier, QB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Don Griffin, DB Middle Tennessee
1986 Off. - Mike Clark, TB Akron
Def. - Fred Harvey, LB Eastern Kentucky
1987 Off. - Trenton Lykes, QB Youngstown State
Def. - Aaron Jones, DL Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Paul Solis, LB Youngstown State
1988 Off. - Elroy Harris, TB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Don Thomas, LB Middle Tennessee
1989 Off. - Michael Proctor, QB Murray State
Def. - Anthony Coleman, LB Middle Tennessee
1990 Off. - Joe Campbell, TB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Marty Carter, DB Middle Tennessee
1991 Off. - Markus Thomas, TB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - David Wilkins, DE Eastern Kentucky
1992 Off. - Markus Thomas, TB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Mike Caldwell, LB Middle Tennessee
1993 Off. - Kippy Bayless, TB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Chad Bratzke, DE Eastern Kentucky
1994 Off. - Kippy Bayless, TB Middle Tennessee
Def. - Doug Berg, DL Southeast Missouri
1995 Off. - Derrick Cullors, TB Murray State
Def. - William Hampton, DB Murray State
1996 Off. - Mike Cherry, QB Murray State
Def. - Tony McCombs, LB Eastern Kentucky
1997 Off. - Tyrone Butterfield, WR Tennessee State
Off. - Simon Fuentes, QB Eastern Kentucky
Def. - Angel Rubio, DL Southeast Missouri
1998 Off. - Leon Murray, QB Tennessee State
Def. - Branon Vaughn, DE Tennessee Tech
1999 Off. - Justin Fuente, QB Murray State
Def. - Lamar Carter, DE Tennessee State
2000 Off. - Tony Romo, QB Eastern Illinois
Def. - Chad Evitts, LB Tennessee Tech
2001 Off. - Tony Romo, QB Eastern Illinois
Def. - Yeremiah Bell, DB Eastern Kentucky
2002 Off. - Tony Romo, QB Eastern Illinois
Def. - Nick Ricks, LB Eastern Illinois
2003 Off. - Efrem Hill, WR Samford
Def. - Cortland Finnegan, DB Samford
2004 Off. - Charles Anthony, RB Tennessee State
Def. - Justen Rivers, LB Eastern Kentucky