1948-49 Western Kentucky
1949-50 Eastern Kentucky
1950-51 Murray State
1951-52 Western Kentucky
1952-53 Western Kentucky
1953-54 Western Kentucky
1954-55 Eastern Kentucky
1963-64 Murray State
1964-65 Western Kentucky
1965-66 Western Kentucky
1966-67 Tennessee Tech
1974-75 Middle Tennessee
1975-76 Western Kentucky
1976-77 Middle Tennessee
1977-78 Western Kentucky
1978-79 Eastern Kentucky
1979-80 Western Kentucky
1980-81 Western Kentucky
1981-82 Middle Tennessee
1982-83 Morehead State
1983-84 Morehead State
1984-85 Middle Tennessee
1985-86 Akron
1986-87 Austin Peay
1987-88 Murray State
1988-89 Middle Tennessee
1989-90 Murray State
1990-91 Murray State
1991-92 Murray State
1992-93 Tennessee State
1993-94 Tennessee State
1994-95 Murray State
1995-96 Austin Peay
1996-97 Murray State
1997-98 Murray State
1998-99 Murray State
1999-00 Southeast Missouri
2000-01 Eastern Illinois
2001-02 Murray State
2002-03 Austin Peay
2003-04 Murray State
2004-05 Eastern Kentucky