1975 Steve Peeler, Middle Tennessee
1976 Johnny Britt, Western Kentucky
1977 Bob Martin, Middle Tennessee
1978 Otis Howard, Austin Peay
1979 Greg Jackson, Western Kentucky
1980 Craig McCormick, Western Kentucky
1981 Lamont Sleets, Murray State
1982 Craig McCormick, Western Kentucky
1983 Guy Minnifield, Morehead State
1984 Earl Harrison, Morehead State
1985 John Keshock, Youngstown State
1986 Eric McLaughlin, Akron
1987 Darryl Bedford, Austin Peay
1988 Jeff Martin, Murray State
1989 Keith Rawls, Austin Peay
1990 Popeye Jones, Murray State
1991 Popeye Jones, Murray State
1992 Popeye Jones, Murray State
1993 Monty Wilson, Tennessee State
1994 Carlos Rogers, Tennessee State
1995 Marcus Brown, Murray State
1996 Bubba Wells, Austin Peay
1997 Chad Townsend, Murray State
1998 Chad Townsend, Murray State
1999 Aubrey Reese, Murray State
2000 Roderick Johnson, Southeast Missouri
2001 Kyle Hill, Eastern Illinois
2002 Justin Burdine, Murray State
2003 Josh Lewis, Austin Peay
2004 Cuthbert Victor, Murray State
2005 Michael Haney, Eastern Kentucky