1962-63 Harold Sergent, Morehead State
1963-64 Jim Jennings, Murray State
1964-65 Clem Haskins, Western Kentucky
1965-66 Clem Haskins, Western Kentucky
1966-67 Clem Haskins, Western Kentucky
1967-68 Wayne Chapman, Western Kentucky
Harley Swift, East Tennessee
1968-69 Claude Virden, Murray State
1969-70 Jim McDaniels, Western Kentucky
1970-71 Jim McDaniels, Western Kentucky
1971-72 Les Taylor, Murray State
1972-73 Les Taylor, Murray State
1973-74 James Williams, Austin Peay
1974-75 George Sorrell, Middle Tennessee
1975-76 Tim Sisneros, Middle Tennessee
Johnny Britt, Western Kentucky
1976-77 Otis Howard, Austin Peay
1977-78 Otis Howard, Austin Peay
1978-79 James Tillman, Eastern Kentucky
1979-80 Gary Hooker, Murray State
1980-81 Jerry Beck, Middle Tennessee
1981-82 Jerry Beck, Middle Tennessee
1982-83 Glen Green, Murray State
Joe Jakubick, Akron
1983-84 Joe Jakubick, Akron
1984-85 Stephen Kite, Tennessee Tech
1985-86 Marcel Boyce, Akron
1986-87 Bob McCann, Morehead State
1987-88 Jeff Martin, Murray State
1988-89 Jeff Martin, Murray State
1989-90 Popeye Jones, Murray State
1990-91 Popeye Jones, Murray State
1991-92 Brett Roberts, Morehead State
1992-93 Carlos Rogers, Tennessee State
1993-94 Carlos Rogers, Tennessee State
1994-95 Marcus Brown, Murray State
1995-96 Marcus Brown, Murray State
1996-97 Bubba Wells, Austin Peay
1997-98 De'Teri Mayes, Murray State
1998-99 Bud Eley, Southeast Missouri
1999-00 Aubrey Reese, Murray State
2000-01 Trenton Hassell, Austin Peay
2001-02 Henry Domercant, Eastern Illinois
2002-03 Ricky Minard, Morehead State
2003-04 Cuthbert Victor, Murray State
2004-05 Willie Jenkins, Tennessee Tech